The recommendation from the National Sleep Foundation is that adults need between seven and nine hours of sleep each night. Children need even more. Since you’ll be spending so much time in bed, wouldn’t it be great if your mattress could stay as fresh and protected as the day you bought it? Sure it would. Below, we will review the best mattress protector available.
The problem is, the mattress gods dictate that anything and everything: sweat from your body, drool, your dog, kid, aunt flow…the really yummy cup of hot chocolate that slipped out of your hand and innumerable other things will stain, soil, and/or damage your mattress. Not to mention microscopic allergens and other nuisances. Fortunately, there's a solution.
The best way to ensure you can preserve your mattress is to purchase the best mattress protector you can find. A good mattress protector will help prevent moisture, mildew, sweat, and even bedwetting from damaging your mattress. It can also have health benefits like reducing symptoms of eczema, asthma, and/or severe allergies. Some even create a barrier against dust mites and bed bugs. Most are hypoallergenic.
That said, there are so many mattress protectors on the market, and they are not all created equal. We put this best mattress protectors guide together to make your search a little easier. So, before you go shopping, let’s discuss a few mattress protector FAQ’s and review the five mattress protectors we feel may be best for you.
5 Best Mattress Protector Comparison Table
Mattress Protectors FAQ’s
1. What Are Encasement Mattress Protectors?
Encasement mattress protectors are essentially an encasement cover, or a zippered mattress protector. They are designed to fit around the whole mattress. When made of the right material, they are ideal for protection against spills and stains. Encasement protectors can also slow down wear and tear of your mattress. Zipper closures are most common on those that provide security against dust mites and bed bugs. Encasement protectors are great for children because they are less likely to come off.
That said, be sure to pick one in a material that won’t trap moisture or heavily block airflow. For example, those made from fabric blends are thin and breathable. In contrast, vinyl or plastic trap in heat and moisture. The exception to the rule are bed bug encasement covers. They will require a sacrifice of breathability and have a more limited material choice.
2. What Is A Fitted Sheet Mattress Protector?
Fitted Sheet protectors cover a mattress like a fitted sheet. They are the easiest style to put on and remove. Most fitted sheet protectors are machine washable. Fitted sheet protectors are best suited for keeping bacteria and fluids away from your mattress. They will often be advertised as hypoallergenic, and are useful if you have allergies. That said, their one drawback is that they do leave the bottom of your mattress uncovered, and thus are not effective for preventing bed bugs and dust mites.
3. What Are The Benefits Of A Padded Mattress Protector?
Padded mattress protectors to the job of a regular protector, but also give your mattress added softness and slow its breakdown so, they may not be the best mattress protectors. However, they will also change the feel of your mattress. Many are too bulky to be machine washable. At some point, depending on the filling and construction, they may get lumpy. It is arguable that they are not as effective against spills and stains as most are not waterproof.
4. Why Is A Mattress Protectors Pore Size Important?
If you are concerned about allergens, the pore size of a mattress protector is important. Pore size is the size of the openings in a fabric's weave. They are measured in microns. The smaller the pore size, the fewer chance allergens will reside in your mattress. Do note that decreased pore size limits airflow. So your bed will feel warmer.
5. What Is The Difference Between A Mattress Protector And A Mattress Pad?
A mattress protector preserves your investment by ensuring your mattress won't be damaged. A mattress pad, which changes the comfort of the bed does not.
How We Reviewed The Best Mattress Protector
The mattress protectors we chose were reviewed based on the following parameters: features, pros and cons, price, where to buy, and warranty. We personally chose all protectors featured. No protectors on our list were provided to us by the companies. Our review of each product is completely unbiased, and based on our opinions and the opinions of other consumers.
Overall Price Range Of This Product
Mattress protectors range in price from about 20 dollars to 300 dollars. Higher priced mattress protectors are often encasement style and have more protection guarantees. Lower priced mattress protectors may not last as long, and will mostly be a fitted sheet type. Material quality may likely vary as well.
What We Reviewed
Slumber Cloud Dryline Mattress Protector
Cloud Dryline Mattress Protector features an impermeable that is still breathable and waterproof. It also is dust mite and allergen resistant while protecting against stains and liquids. Fits mattresses up to 20 inches deep.
10 Year Warranty.
SafeRest Mattress Protector
- Protects Against Dust Mites, Fluids, Urine, Perspiration, Allergens And Bacteria (10-Year Warranty)
- Hypoallergenic Cotton Terry Surface With Membrane Back Coating (Waterproof, Noiseless and...
- Great For Those With Kids, Pets, Allergies, Asthma, Eczema Or Incontinence (OEKO-TEX Certified SH025...
SafeRest Mattress Pad protects against dust mites, fluids, perspiration, allergens, and bacteria. It is ideal for those with allergies, asthma, eczema, or incontinence. It is registered with the FDA as a Class 1 medical device.
10 Year Warranty.
LUCID Waterproof Mattress Protector
- 100% Waterproof - repels all liquids including bodily fluids, perspiration, urine and accidental...
- Noiseless and comfortable hypoallergenic cotton terry surface and polyurethane backing inhibits...
- Fully-elasticized fitted sheet style with deep pockets designed to fit mattresses up to 22 inches...
LUCID Waterproof Mattress Protector is a fitted sheet styled mattress protector. It boasts being 100 percent waterproof and hypoallergenic. It is designed to fit mattresses up to 22 inches deep.
15 Year Warranty.
Luna Mattress Protectors
- Protects against allergens, dust mites, bacteria, perspiration, urine and fluids (15-Year Warranty)
- 100% waterproof membrane with fitted sheet style design - Queen Size (60" x 80" fits up to 18" deep)
- Luna Airflow Technology allows air to circulate through the protector, but repels liquids
Luna Mattress Protectors protect against allergens, dust mites, bacteria, perspiration, urine, and fluids. It claims to have a 100 percent waterproof membrane with a fitted sheet style design. The protector also uses Luna Airflow Technology, meaning the protector allows air to circulate while still repelling liquids. It is constructed from a hypoallergenic cotton terry that naturally absorbs moisture.
15 Year Warranty.
Protect-A-Bed Therm-A-Sleep Snow Protector
Protect-a-Bed Therm-A-Sleep Snow Protector is made of an all-natural Eucalyptus fiber that is manufactured without pesticides. It features the trademarked Miracle Membrane®, which provides a barrier against dust mites, liquids, and other irritants. It is Machine wash with a tumble dry. The protector is hypoallergenic, which is beneficial for those with sensitive skin or skin disorders such as eczema
10 Year Warranty.
We really wanted to go with the Luna Mattress Protector for our top pick because we love a well-made American product. However, Luna will have to take the second slot because our number one best mattress protector won by a landslide. Protect-a-Bed Therm-A-Sleep Snow Protector indisputably at the top of our list of the best mattress protectors.
We basically have no complaints about this protector except that it is only a fitted sheet styled protector and not encased. A few buyers felt it made their beds warm, but most were satisfied. You know you have a winner when almost everyone loves your product.
Using a pesticide-free Eucalyptus fiber was a unique touch we appreciated. As was the proprietary moisture barrier choice. It is the only protector on our list that received no complaints about leaking, which says a lot. The ten-year warranty is a bonus and, since Protect-a-Bed has been a household name for decades, we feel confident they’ll back it.
We give the Protect-a-Bed Therm-A-Sleep Snow Protector $$ out of $$$ because it is midrange in cost. The full encasement version of the Protect-a-Bed cover would likely take the $$$ place.